“…only mass social movements can save us now.” Naomi Klein, This Changes Everything: Capitalism vs. The Climate
“….this impossibly thin blue curve keeps everything alive beneath it.” Reid Wiseman, #spacetweets.
For starters, take two and a half minutes to watch astronaut Reid Wiseman’s video, “A Photo I Love,” and then come back here. You’ll see a new view of Italy (some of you know how much I love Italy). Notice in particular Reid’s photo of the earth’s atmosphere, “….so blue, so incredibly thin….” and Reid’s tweets (#spacetweets).
I wanted to begin on an upbeat note, hence Reid’s video of “watching our earth be alive” that so vividly highlights what the stakes are when it comes to the climate debate. It’s not that Canadian journalist Naomi Klein doesn’t offer hope in her latest book, This Changes Everything. Certainly, she does, but this is a read with plenty of emotional lows before you get to the highs.
This Changes Everything is proving to be enormously influential as well as controversial. If I read her correctly, Klein does not advocate a dismantling of capitalism, but her book is indeed a polemic against the extreme version of capitalism that pervades much of the world today. Her message is that the earth cannot possibly continue to sustain a world economy based on unlimited growth and the endless extraction of resources. We need to change course to keep the earth’s warming under two degrees Celsius (this is according to many climate scientists, who also maintain that a warming of four degrees Celsius would be catastrophic). We need to act now, on a massive scale.
If you care deeply about climate change, I highly recommend putting This Changes Everything at the top of your to-read list. There is so much I don’t know about this huge topic. Though I’ve been against fracking (recently outlawed here in New York), I didn’t know much about it, and I knew absolutely nothing of Canada’s tar sands project and its devastations. Klein brought me up to date on all of this, as well as the current climate change activist scene. She synthesized an enormous amount of research, which makes for slow reading at times, but it’s worth it if you want the big picture.
Here are some things I learned that surprised me:
- We’ve come a long way with alternative energy technologies. It seems like a no-brainer – if we can meet our energy needs at very little cost using solar, wind, and other technologies, why would we continue using expensive and dirty fossil fuels?
- Native Americans and indigenous populations around the world are winning important victories against the fossil fuel industry, more so than activists in the mainstream. In Canada and the US, for example, some of these groups, by treaty, retain rights to their land, including the right to make a living from it. The courts have, in many cases, upheld these rights, effectively blocking or delaying extraction projects. These delays have given alternative energy technologies time to develop.
- Though it’s important for developed countries to convert to clean energy, it’s crucial that we help developing countries turn to clean energy, too–otherwise we’ll never be able to stop global warming. Klein and others maintain that, since developed countries have grown wealthy from fossil fuels, we have a responsibility to help developing countries pay for their energy infrastructures.
A New York Times review called This Changes Everything “…the most momentous and contentious book since Silent Spring,” and “…a book of such ambition and consequence it is almost unreviewable.”
This Changes Everything is absolutely a book that can save lives.
Have you read This Changes Everything? Do you recommend other important books about this topic? If so, please do in the comments. And if you care about climate change, I hope you’ll share this post.
7 thoughts on “This Changes Everything”
My husband has this book on his bedstand, but neither of us has read it yet. Your review of it is excellent. Does it offer any possible ways to go about changing global economics the way it is now?
Well, it’s complicated. Naomi believes only mass protesting and social movements can get us to do anything about climate change. As for changing global economics – some thought leaders believe capitalism has seen its day, and as economics becomes more locally based (locally grown food, local wind/solar farms, and lots more) the entire corporate economic structure will change. For example, in some respects if you have your home heated by solar power, do don’t need to be paying an energy company….if you grow your own food….etc. I think in her book Naomi deals mostly with…where are we now and what must happen….one great hope is social protest and learning from the indigenous groups….so glad you like the review hope you read her book.
Thanks for such a thoughtful response, Valerie!
[…] This Changes Everything, by Naomi Klein […]
Climate change is one of those topics that has joined, religion, politics, and the use of pesticides. Glad you were brave enough to discuss it. 🙂
No, climate change should not be an off limits topic. If it is, than I believe we are in serious trouble. People should be free to speak their mind no matter their opinions.
I totally agree it is a topic that needs to be addressed but it certainly is one that people are at extremes about. 🙂