“She is fascinated but not dismayed to discover that she has forgotten so much.
Is she really the same woman who celebrated Easter 1889 in Athens and walked up to the Acropolis with her husband?
Who spent a ‘most interesting day viewing the cisterns of Carthage’ with Victor and Armand in 1896?
Who once wrote on her anniversary in 1900, in an apartment on 97 rue de la Pompe in Paris, ‘In afternoon we went to Exp. and up the Trocadéro tower, then to Élysée Palace Hotel, saw King Leopold come in. In evening at dinner we ordered St. Honoré and champagne. M. Guerrier got up and improvised a poem and there was much gaiety and good humor. Armand gave me a gold watch charm’?” De Potter’s Grand Tour, Joanna Scott
This much, we know: In 1905, Joanna Scott’s great grandfather disappeared while on board a ship off the coast of Greece. A collector of ancient Egyptian art (some of it is at the Brooklyn Museum) and a world tour guide, he was at his wit’s end, hounded by creditors and litigators.
The question is: Did he commit suicide? Was he pushed overboard? Or, did he fake his own death and assume a new identity, leaving behind his beloved wife, Aimée, and his son?
How would you like to inherit that family mystery?
Joanna Scott did, in the form of Armand’s letters, postcards, photos, and documents, and the multi-volume journal of his wife, Aimée. This treasure trove had been sitting in a steamer trunk in Scott’s mother’s storage unit for years, until one day they unearthed it while searching for a diploma.
Intrigued, Scott threw herself into research and began writing a nonfiction account of Armand de Potter’s life. Ultimately, that proved too confining: Scott discovered that the mysterious and elusive Armand wasn’t who he said he was, and no one knew, not even his wife. So Scott switched to fiction, which gave her more freedom to suppose and imagine.
I read this novel ages ago and never got around to posting about it, but the book has stayed with me all this time. It’s not for everyone–Joanna Scott is a celebrated writer, but this particular novel didn’t garner the best of reviews.
I, on the other hand, loved it. I loved the larger-than-life way Armand and Aimée lived traveling all over the world leading their educational tours. Armand was an autodidact who pretended to be descended from Belgian royalty and more educated than he was. Nonetheless, as Scott portrays him, he was a scholar and a lover of the world with a passion for sharing that love with the people who signed up for his tours.
“To travel is to live,” Armand de Potter wrote in one of the documents Scott found in the steamer trunk.
His tour company went to these places: Algeria, Austria, Belgium, Czech Republic, Egypt, England, France, Germany, Gibralter, Greece, Hong Kong, Hungary, India, Italy, Japan, Malaysia, Monaco, Netherlands, Romania, Scotland, Singapore, Spain, Sri Lanka, Switzerland, Tunisia, Turkey, various locations in the US, and Yemen.
Some time in the late 1800s, Armand also wrote this prescient and hopeful passage: “The incalculable benefits of foreign travel can only be half told by our children….They will be appreciated by their sons and daughters, at a time when travel will have made the world very small and the human race what it is destined to be–one great fraternity.”
If you’re an armchair traveler, if you love history, and if you want an unusual story, I think you might like De Potter’s Grand Tour.
I enjoy Joanna Scott’s novels a great deal. One of my all-time favorites is Liberation, which takes place in Sicily, one of my favorite places in the world, during World War II. Scott is a much loved Professor of English here at the University of Rochester.
Speaking of family history, I’m off to a family reunion next week, where we’ll be reading a book loosely connected with a couple of the more colorful family members. I’ll tell you about it when I return.
I’ll leave you with what Armand de Potter had to say about good books (I would also add “women” of course):
“In the most beautiful books, great men speak with us, they give their most precious thoughts, and pour their soul into ours. Let us thank God for the creation of books. They are the voices of those that are far and of those that are dead; they make us heirs of the intellectual life of the past ages. Books furnish to all those who will use them with sincerity the society, the spiritual presences of the best and the greatest men.”
12 thoughts on “Off the Beaten Path: De Potter’s Grand Tour”
CIAO E SALUTI AFFETTUOSI
________________________________ Da: Books Can Save A Life Inviato: venerdì 5 agosto 2016 20.51 A: firstname.lastname@example.org Oggetto: [New post] Off the Beaten Path: De Potter’s Grand Tour
Valorie Grace Hallinan posted: ” “She is fascinated but not dismayed to discover that she has forgotten so much. Is she really the same woman who celebrated Easter 1889 in Athens and walked up to the Acropolis with her husband? Who spent a ‘most interesting day viewing the cist”
Now that is one intriguing mystery! And perhaps a good thing she switched to fiction, so perhaps we’ll get an answer? 🙂 I haven’t read any of her works, so cannot judge, but the premise of DePotter sounds pretty cool!
I can’t even imagine what it must be like to have an ancestor who left behind so much rich stuff.
Thanks, Ben, and thanks for your help!
Interesting she chose to write the story as fiction rather than nonfiction. did she ever find out what happened to him? Have fun at the family reunion!
No one will ever know at this point! Thanks!
This sounds like something I would like! I love historical novels based on true events. Thanks for introducing me to this book – I think I’ll also check out some of her others!
I hope you like her!
I love the idea of grand tours and travel in the Victorian era, and I love history so I’m quite sure I would enjoy this, based on your description. I hadn’t heard of it before. Thanks for bringing it to my attention.
Debbie, I hope you like it!
I read and enjoyed this book a while back. I picked it up just on the strong appeal of the cover art and the title !!